This is the version which was re-released in 1942. The original film was tightened up a bit. A score was added, and Chaplin recorded a narration for it. This goes a long way to making the movie palatable for a modern audience. There's a lot of interpretation that would have been involved otherwise.
It's an interesting movie. It's funny, but it has some dark elements to it. There's a sequence that was intended to lead the audience to think that a dog had been eaten out of hunger, and another scene where two starving guys eat a shoe. These gags are handled well, but it still gives a very depression-era feeling to things.
The humor is largely physical, and Chaplin is a lot of fun to watch. The early state of film direction at the time works against some of his skills - there are some moments where he gives some masterful expressions. A lot of scenes seem to be handled in longer takes, although some awkward edits are in there.
His dance using the rolls is remarkable. It's a silly piece of comedy, but I haven't seen anything like it in modern times.
No comments:
Post a Comment